Episode 23
Your Retail Sales Are Fine. Your Profits Aren't. Here's Why.
Your retail sales are fine.
Your profits aren’t.
Here’s why.
Hi, I’m Clare Bailey, founder of Retail Champion.
In this episode of Retail Reckoning, I’m joined by Graeme Sharp from Sharper Margins.
We'll be unpacking where retail profits really disappear and why it’s rarely down to one big dramatic mistake.
This isn’t an episode about paranoia, security theatre, or treating your team like suspects.
It’s about the small, everyday losses that quietly erode margin and add up far faster than most retailers expect.
We talk about why shoplifting is only part of the story, how mispricing, admin errors, poor stock control, and broken processes quietly drain profit, and why relying on instinct alone stops working as your business grows.
This episode isn’t about complicated systems or expensive tech.
It’s about awareness, consistency, and simple controls that actually protect your margin.
This episode breaks down:
Why retail profits leak even when sales look healthy
The hidden losses most retailers underestimate
How poor stock accuracy quietly destroys margin
Why trust and control aren’t opposites
What retailers should focus on in the next 90 days to protect profit
If your business looks busy but the money never quite stacks up, this episode will help you understand what’s really going on behind the scenes.
Fewer leaks.
More clarity.
Healthier margins.
Let’s get your Retail Reckoning together.
Useful links:
Subscribe to the Retail Reckoning Newsletter
https://retailreckoningpodcast.co.uk/newsletter
Retail Champion: https://theretailchampion.co.uk
Mentioned in this episode:
Retail Reckoning Podcast Insights Newsletter
Get Retail Reckoning Podcast Insights and Goodies - https://retailreckoningpodcast.co.uk/newsletter
Retail Reckoning Podcast VIP newsletter
Transcript
Profit protection without killing the joy. We're talking about something that might sound rather dry at first, margin, stop, loss and risk.
2
:CLARE: But the truth is, this stuff is the difference between surviving and thriving. Welcome back to Retail Reckoning.
3
:CLARE: I'm Clare Bailey, the retail champion, and today we're talking about something that isn't necessarily top of everybody's list, but it's something that can make a real difference and turn sales into profits.
4
:CLARE: So joining me today is Graeme Sharp, one of the associate consultants with Retail Champion and also founder of Sharper Margins.
5
:CLARE: Graeme's been behind the curtains of so many different retail businesses over the years, and he knows where the real leaks happen to your profit.
6
:GRAEME: Thanks Clare. Happy to show people that protecting profit doesn't have to be scary or boring.
7
:CLARE: When people hear things like loss prevention, don't they immediately switch off and just think it's about security guards and shoplifters?
8
:CLARE: So how do you have those conversations with retailers to make it more strategic?
9
:GRAEME: Loss prevention has evolved over the years from security to loss prevention, and more recently profit protection and risk.
10
:GRAEME: People hear the words loss prevention and generally panic, think it's gonna cost them money or think it's gonna get them into trouble.
11
:GRAEME: In reality, I can't recall a time when the retail sector has been so challenged.
12
:GRAEME: Profits are being squeezed, increases in operating costs, payroll, all impact profitability.
13
:GRAEME: Add to this unprecedented levels of retail crime and you have a near perfect storm.
14
:GRAEME: Consequently, it's never been more vital to have a really good understanding of loss prevention in your business.
15
:GRAEME: Most retailers think their biggest problem is a supplier issue or poor sales, when in reality it's often repeated leaks.
16
:GRAEME: Mispriced items, small shrinkage, unnoticed returns, things that eat away at your margins.
17
:GRAEME: Every pound has the same impact on your bottom line, whether it's through theft, damages, admin, pricing errors or unnecessary spend.
18
:CLARE: Absolutely. A death by a thousand cuts. It's not a massive mistake like a container sinking off the coast.
19
:CLARE: It's someone dropping something on the floor, a two pound loss here, something not put through the till properly there.
20
:CLARE: And over time, it all adds up.
21
:GRAEME: Exactly right, Clare. Many retailers blame shoplifting, but it's only part of the story.
22
:GRAEME: Internal dishonesty, process errors and supply chain loss often make up a much larger proportion.
23
:CLARE: I've been climbing around dusty warehouses during stock takes years ago, and often they were in such a mess.
24
:CLARE: It was a miracle anyone knew what stock they even had.
25
:CLARE: Getting inventory placed correctly and doing accurate stock takes means knowing what you've got, where it is and what condition it's in.
26
:GRAEME: The biggest part of a stock take is preparation. Really good preparation delivers great stock take results.
27
:GRAEME: Use your best people to do the count. Store teams know where stock hides, the nooks and crannies.
28
:GRAEME: If you use an external provider, make sure it's a blended approach with your own people supporting.
29
:GRAEME: Audit the count. Check the checkers. The data must be accurate so you can actually work with it.
30
:CLARE: You told me that story about a staff member stealing stock and leaving in winter without a coat.
31
:GRAEME: They were stealing around a thousand pounds of designer product per shift, hiding it under clothing.
32
:GRAEME: Over a few weeks they stole over fifty thousand pounds at cost.
33
:CLARE: You can't just assume someone is trustworthy. You need checks and balances.
34
:GRAEME: People cause one hundred percent of loss. Systems only do what people instruct them to do.
35
:GRAEME: Monitor trends, behaviour changes, and be open about why controls exist.
36
:CLARE: So it's small regular checks, not micromanagement.
37
:GRAEME: An over reliance on tech without understanding data is a huge mistake.
38
:CLARE: Consistency beats expensive tech used badly.
39
:GRAEME: There's no simple answer, but there are simple actions.
40
:GRAEME: Knee jerk reactions to stock loss often make things worse.
41
:GRAEME: Smart leaders maintain controls whether results are good or bad.
42
:GRAEME: We supported a store where profit improved once stock was protected and staff felt safer.
43
:GRAEME: Loss prevention became about enabling sales, not policing.
44
:CLARE: Cost of living pressures have changed behaviour, and staff need support and training.
45
:GRAEME: Trust and control must be balanced through clear processes.
46
:GRAEME: Shortcuts like shared codes and keys cause devastating losses.
47
:GRAEME: An ex employee emptied a safe because basic controls weren't followed.
48
:CLARE: What three things should retailers do in the next ninety days?
49
:GRAEME: Focus on key products, do simple regular counts, and use your data together.
50
:CLARE: Keep checking, observing, and staying aware.
51
:CLARE: Thank you Graeme. Simple human steps keep businesses healthy.
52
:CLARE: I'm Clare Bailey and this has been Retail Reckoning.
